About Eighteen-Ninety Sleepover

Built by the Knights of Pythius in 1890, this former meeting hall has been renovated to an early 1900s themed Sleepover.

Kimberlee Davidson-Russell purchased the building from Casey Township on  February 9th, 2016.

Over the next 18 months, the building's second and third floors were gutted and rebuilt to display the rich history.

The rooms are spacious and have many modern amenities while showcasing the characteristics of a building that was constructed in 1890.

Visitors can tour our quaint, small town while visiting many of the worlds largest attractions.

Enjoy a cupcake at the bakery or a specialty ice cream next to the Candy Depot while listening to the music playing downtown daily.

We hope you enjoy these photos below of our transformation.


Search Available Dates








Enter your details




If you have a coupon code enter it in the field below and click on apply.





Reservation summary

Thanks for your reservation! We have just sent you a confirmation email at with the following details:

Check-in: - Change
Check-out: - Change
Number of nights:
Adults: - Change
Children: - Change
Accommodation: - Change

Accommodation price: $
Price includes:
Options price: -$
Coupon discount amount: $
Discount amount: $

Total price: $

See you soon!


Safe and secure payments SSL encrypted


Your credit card will not be charged until time of stay.




“This place is brand new, and it is absolutely beautiful!! It's in the perfect spot for anyone wanting to go to Casey to explore all of those "Big Things in a Little Town"!!! Kimberlee is a wonderful host and was very accommodating to all of our needs!! It is very obvious that this place is near and dear to her heart...everything in it is super nice...the towels, the bed linens, the soap products, all of it!! We loved it there and have every intention of going back!! :)”



We recently had some friends come into town to stay for a weekend. We used that opportunity to stay at the newly renovated 1890 Sleepover in downtown Casey. This property is excellent! They have meticulously renovated their rooms and each one is unique. The building has original exposed brick walls, 12-foot ceilings, and beautiful hardwood floors. Each room is well appointed and has a small kitchenette and a very accommodating bathroom with subway tile shower and turn of the century accents. Just off Main St. this hotel is a 1-2 minute walk to the several World’s Largest items on Main Street in Casey. If you’re coming to Casey this is the place to stay!
—Adam - Betsy


Wonderfully renovated historic building in a fun little town. Kim was an impeccable hostess! Definitely worth a diversion from Effingham. We’ll be back.

Get In Touch

We would love to hear from you!

p 217.232.2959
f 217.932.2497
e 1890sleepover@gmail.com

14 S. Central Avenue, Casey, Illinois 62420

Accommodations in Casey, Illinois. Hotel. Place to stay. Accommodations / Hotel near Eastern Illinois University, Charleston. Big Things in a Small Town. Accommodations / Hotel near Indiana State University, Terre Haute. Hotel.